News of Margie’s is quickly spreading through my Chicago posse. Maybe it’s just because I’ve been working on reviving this blog for the last few months, but I keep finding myself at Margie’s with a new group of people.
This time, I was joined by Anna and Jimena—two friends intrigued by both my journey and my rave review of Margie’s fudge. It was a lovely summer day, perfect for sitting out on Margie’s patio. Aside from the roar of passing Brown Line trains, the vibes could not be harshed.
It was also my first time trying Margie’s take-out window, a luxury of Chicago’s summer season. While this set-up beckons more patrons, and thus creates a longer line, it gave us plenty of time to ponder our options.
I told my two companions that whatever they did, they had to get something with fudge. Get whatever flavor you want, but let the fudge be the true guide in your judgement of Margie’s quality. They took my advice.
I opted for a smaller treat: the Junior Sundae. Which, dare I say, may be the perfect size for a late night sweet treat.
This is actually my first taste of Margie’s basic sundae. No turtle or cherry flavoring to get in the way of me and that fudge. And what can I say? It was an absolute hit.
Quality of Toppings
The basics: Cream, cherries, and toasted nuts. The more I get into cooking, the less I’m convinced toasting nuts adds much to my cuisine. Peanuts, however, are the exclusion. Getting raw chopped peanuts on my sundaes simply doesn’t do it for me anymore.
Quality of Fudge
As perfect as ever. No notes. Anna and Jimena were overjoyed as well—they gasped, awed, and shrieked at the complexity of this sweet sweet fudge from this sweet sweet woman (Margie).
Level of Comfort Ordering a Hot Fudge Sundae
The take-out window was a little intimidating, I’ll admit. But the line gave me plenty of time to calm my nerves and rattle off my order.
Would I Rather Eat a McDonald’s Hot Fudge Sundae?
With fudge like this? No way. Barring the artificial fruit flavors from round 2, Margie’s stomps McDonald’s any day of the week. That said, I may prefer their turtle sundae over the basic toppings. Maybe I’m really just pining for that massive quantity I missed with this sundae. Further research is required.
Final Score: 9.5/10
Hot for Fudge 